The dilemma of a millennial bookworm

April 7, 2010 in Life,Philosophy,Travel

Confession: I am a bookworm. Literally, I was the child who walked to school with her nose in a book and couldn’t wait for her weekly trip to the library. (I was also a huge nerd growing up, but let’s save the discussion of my awkward childhood for another day.)

All grown up, and I still haven’t had my fill of reading. In the words of one of my favorite authors, Elizabeth Gilbert: “Dear me, how I love a library.” I keep a paperback stored in my purse at all times in case of long lines, waiting rooms and rides on public transportation.  I love the feeling of turning the page, the smell of fresh new paper, the way the binding cracks as you break in a new book.

My love affair with books doesn’t end when I travel. Needless to say, I stash books in my carry-on for the plane and extras in my luggage for when I arrive. I have a knack for finding English-language bookstores when I out-read my supply.

But as much as I can’t resist the allure of an old-fashioned paperback, I’m also a product of Silicon Valley. I adore any tech gadget that can make my life easier–and the more that I think about it, the more sense the Kindle (or Nook or perhaps the brand-new iPad, or any other e-reader) seems to make.

Despite how much I adore turning an actual page, I realized how an e-reader would make traveling easier for a reader. Lighter luggage? Check. Having another book ready to go when one is finished? Check. A supply of more than a million English-language titles– rather than two shelves in a bookstore? Check.  Although I’m hesitant because of the pricetag, an e-reader seems to be a win-win purchase.

However, my mom made a good point when I mentioned purchasing a Kindle. The main reason I’m going to Nice is to improve my French–will having an unlimited supply of English books negatively affect my immersion experience? As much as I hate to admit it (again), I had to agree with her. I’ll be getting my fill of English through tweeting, blogging and Facebooking. I probably should spend my offline hours plugged into my French studies.

Yet to all my fellow bookworms out there, I ask you this: can you give up the traditional book buying experience? Wandering a bookstore, reading the back covers, snuggling into bed or curling up on the couch with your brand-new find, that feeling of satisfaction (or frustration or pure joy) when you turn over the last page. Can that be replaced with an online bookstore, scrolling instead of turning, a click instead of a beloved bookmark between the pages?

Have you taken an e-reader on your travels? Did you find it more convenient and travel-friendly? Or will you stick to extra books packed in luggage and magazines from the airport gift store?

  • http://www.prolificliving.com/blog prolificliving

    How interesting that you ask this very question. Today I posted on my facebook: Shall I buy a Kindle (or new iPad) if I am a book lover and love the feeling of turning the pages. I love reading and in fact my blog started out as a book blog – I decided not only will I read incessantly into my old age but since I will most likely forget the intricate details, a long review of each book is in order. SO to answer your question, much as I like to agree with Moms, go ahead and buy a Kindle. You can buy French books on it I am sure. You want to keep up your English (believe me it's possible to forget our own mother tongue, I nearly have) and being a multi-lingual is nothing for a girl of this day and age. :) Let me know how the Kindle works out or I let you know if I go for it first!

  • LostInCheeseland

    Wrote about this issue not too long ago – I'm anti-kindle and will forever lug around books no matter how cumbersome, on principle. Rather than repeat myself, here's what I said!! http://www.lostincheeseland.com/2010/02/god-sav

    I can't give up the tangible reading experience!

  • http://twitter.com/ashleygunther Ashley Gunther

    That's strange, I feel like I JUST had this conversation with you! Haha but I'm still torn.

    My vote is get a Kindle for English books (and like your first comment mentioned, I'm sure you can fill it with books in French too–maybe even change your Kindle settings to French for an extra dose?) But then maybe pick up a few French paperbacks while you're there, that way you can throw them in your fantastic new bag and bring them to the beach with no worry of getting your new, expensive gadget wet.

    Also, then you'd have a few souvenirs to bring home instead of just some “I <3 France” shot glass. (<–but I'll take one of these if you see one and feel inclined to bring me back a souvenir! ;) )

  • Kmo139

    As a fellow bookworm, I don't think I could ever give up buying books. I love the feeling of turning pages far too much!

  • RexFlo

    I'm not as obsessed with book buying, but I did feel this same dilemma when the ipod came out. I love buying records/CD's; I admire the album art, I study the liner notes, and I truly believe that rows of alphabetized CD's make for handsome decor. There is something distinctly more satisfying in having a physical copy of a piece of art.
    With that said, since I purchased an ipod, I'm never without it. It's just too damn convenient! I still buy records from time to time, but I download a lot. Kindle seems to me to be the exact same thing. Some books you know you need to buy, but when you're just looking for a quick distraction it makes sense to just download one.

    However, I agree with your ma. Focus on your French, but grab a fat stack of magazines. They're light, easy to pack, and it will encourage a journalist-state of mind.. A writer used “kinda” in my Rolling Stone, and it blew my mind that a professional in such a highly circulated magazine could do that. But that is a separate issue.

  • http://wheremyheartresides.com/ Ashlee

    Such a dilemma! I also find myself caught between my love of books and love of technology. But I think in this instance, I have to vote for books. I already stare at a computer for too many hours each day–why add additional strain to my poor little eyes? Also, a kindle will never smell as good as a fresh book.

  • camorose

    That's definitely a huge part of why I'm not sold on the Kindle. After staring at a screen all day, I love giving my eyes a bit of a break–or at least a change of pace–when I read before going to bed. As techie as I am, I think I'm going to stick to real books for a bit longer.

  • camorose

    That's a great comparison. I dream of one day having a library in my home: a room filled with books from floor to ceiling and a comfy leather chair to sit in. I don't think I'm sold on the Kindle just yet, although I'm sure I'll give in eventually–just as I couldn't see the benefit of iPods when they were first introduced, and now I always have mine with me.
    I'm a huge believer in magazines, so I'm going to stock up at airports along the way–then I can pick up both American, British and French versions!

  • camorose

    I think I'll give in one day, but I don't think it will be before this trip. I'm glad to know there are fellow book-lovers out there!

  • camorose

    I don't think I'm going to spring for the Kindle before I leave–it's a bit expensive when I'm not completely sold yet. Plus, since I'll be in one place, I know that I can buy on Amazon or have my mom ship me over new paperbacks if I need any. However, if I ever decide to do a RTW trip (where the emphasis isn't on language immersion), I think a Kindle will be be a must-have.
    I will admit that I felt the same apprehensiveness about iPods and Twitter–clearly, I'm just a late adopter for technology and trends!

  • camorose

    I remember this post, and absolutely agree. I think that I'll give into the Kindle some day, (just as I gave in to the iPod and Twitter, even when I thought those were pointless when they were first introduced) but I don't want to give up my books quite yet! I love the reading experience too much :)

  • camorose

    I think I'm going to wait for a Kindle if I ever do a RTW trip or travels that aren't focused on language immersion. I already have enough technology to lug with me over to France as it is! Plus, I'm not quite reading to give up the reading experience yet although I think I'll give in to convenience one day. Thanks for weighing in- it's clear that I'm not the only person experiencing this dilemma!

  • http://www.prolificliving.com/blog prolificliving

    Nothing replaces a good book of course…….I am having such a hard time with this decision. I love turning the pages of Tolstoy in the sun on a cool morning with my tea. How can the Kindle live up to that? I don't know…..maybe in combination for other books on the road….!

  • Serendipty74

    Hello there!
    You don't know me, but I am one of your mom's tenants. She knows I LOVE travel so she shared your blog with me. WHICH by the way is FANTASTIC! I was able to go to Germany over the New Year Holiday, and fell in LOVE with Europe! and LOVED Germany!
    To touch on this topic, I have the same love for books as you have blogged. BUT as a “techy” myself, and ahhhhem, an Apple employee… to have an iPad while traveling the world.. will make it even more blissful!

  • camorose

    I'm so glad that you were able to check it out–and even more so that you enjoyed it! I'm not going to lie, I wouldn't say no to an iPad on my travels (I'm already dragging my Macbook with me!). However, I think I'll stick to books for now and invest in an e-reader when I return! Hope you continue to enjoy the blog :)

  • Carter

    I just stumbled upon your blog and love that you picked up and moved to Nice! So many of your posts are worth commenting on, but this one I actually have something to contribute.

    I love books. I was the kid who read in line, read walking, read in class. Still do (except in class), especially since I’m living in London this year and tube rides can be long. Two years ago, I got a Kindle for my birthday, and let me tell you- I love it. The reason I wanted the Kindle instead of another e-reader is because it is specifically designed NOT to strain your eyes. The e-ink and non-backlit screen read like the pages of a regular book, and there’s no issues with taking it out into the sunlight. It is amazing for traveling, because I can carry 100 books (and get 100 more when I finish those) without needing 3 extra bags. I have copies of my favorites on hand whenever I want to re-read them (especially nice since most of my books are in storage at my parents’). And best of all- I still get to read regular books. No one says you have to give up regular books when you get a Kindle. I sure haven’t! One of the first things I did when I got my flat here was sign up for a library card, and I still buy books and swap books with friends just like I always have.

    I think of my Kindle as a marvelous tool that lets me enjoy the world of books even when books are unavailable or inconvenient. Cast it as a delightful supplement to books, and not a replacement for books, and you might find that you can enjoy both.

  • Anonymous

    That’s a great point! I adore libraries, so I could definitely imagine still using those for free books and buying the rest on a Kindle. I haven’t invested in anything yet, but I think the day will be coming soon!

  • http://www.bluegreencorp.com Sidvic

    Hi, I just kind of clicked through and found this post (i love the internet).  I have a nook and I love it! And who says you can’t upload french books on your e-reader (but i guess you already went so my comment would be moot).  Anyhoo, i was JUST having this conversation with a friend of mine. I LOVE the act of reading, the smell of pages.  I even love going to second hand shops and buying older books and having a huge bookshelf. There’s a part of me that’s a little saddened every time i see my old books because i now read almost everything through my nook and i can’t collect anymore But i still do, really. just not as frequently. Sometimes I change my nook case just for a bit of variety lol

     Also, i know the nook lets you rent books too.

    Kudos to you from a fellow bookworm :)

  • Anonymous

    I’m sure I’ll give in to a Kindle one day…but I just love the act of reading too much! I spend so much time on a screen that books are my little release and indulgence :)

  • Pingback: The joy of traveling with a Kindle | C'est Christine

  • http://travelingphoblogwripher.blogspot.com/ Sarabell

    I am a self-published author who sells more than twice as many eBooks than paperbacks. I really rely on the eReader world for my success, and yet I still don’t have an eReader and can’t imagine giving up my beloved physical books. I know I’m not the only one out there with that opinion, but I still feel silly admitting it sometimes!

  • camorose

    I actually did give in and get a Kindle–and there are ups and downs, but I do love the convenience of it :)

Previous post:

Next post: